Deep Hole Creek Conservation
Photo Credit: Rita Rooney
About
Fall 2022 Update:
We are so happy to share that we closed on the “Deep Hole Creek” parcel at 4180 New Suffolk Avenue in Mattituck at the end of June! The Peconic Land Trust is now the interim owner of this property, which has been protected in perpetuity through the simultaneous sale of development rights by the Town of Southold.
We are so grateful to the Koehler family for choosing to collaborate with us, the Town, and YOU, the community, to achieve a conservation outcome. This land will be conserved forever, because so many people cared and joined together in community-focused spirit.
To preserve these 15 acres, once at risk of being subdivided into seven building lots, the Trust came forward as the temporary owner of the property. We will keep you posted in the weeks and months ahead as we steward this land as its interim owner and, importantly, as we seek to find a qualified conservation buyer to acquire the protected property and care for it in the future.
This conservation success story is an incredible outcome in a very short period of time, and is only possible because of community members who have energetically rallied to preserve this land. So far, over $652,000 in donations from community members has been raised toward the purchase and permanent protection of this farmland!
We are so grateful for your continued support and for the amazing progress we continue to make, together.
In late August, donors, community partners, and elected officials gathered at McCall Wines together in celebration of the community’s success in saving the Deep Hole Creek parcel and protecting it forever. By saving this small piece of farmland, this community has made a lasting difference in what the North Fork looks like – now and for future generations. We are so grateful for all you have done to make this project possible!

Speaking to Deep Hole Creek project supporters at the celebratory gathering, Russ McCall offered closing remarks on the importance of community conservation: We are all here because of the places that make the North Fork so special, and it's on us to protect them!

A huge thank you to Russ McCall, Nicola Plimpton, and the McCall family and tasting room staff for generously hosting us at McCall Wines!

An extra special thanks to members of the Deep Hole Creek Steering Committee, who co-hosted the event and helped with setup, cleanup, and provided the beautiful floral arrangements!

Because so many people in the community cared, another piece of the North Fork remains protected, always.

Going, going... SAVED!
Thanks to you, the Deep Hole Creek parcel is protected forever.

We're so grateful for everyone who gave so generously of their time and resources to support this project.

Thank you to the many friends and neighbors who made this conservation success story possible!
Recent Press:
- Suffolk Times article from July 7, 2022, “Peconic Land Trust closes on Deep Hole Creek parcel; community contributed more than $650K”
- Dan’s Papers article from December 2021, “Miracle on New Suffolk Avenue.”
- Suffolk Times article from November 27, 2021, “Deep Hole Creek preservation is near thanks to major community fundraising effort”
- East End Beacon article from November 16, 2021, “A Warp Speed Preservation Effort in Mattituck”
- Suffolk Times article from July 6, 2021, “Over $550,000 raised as conservation buyer sought for Mattituck waterfront property.”
- Suffolk Times article from March 31, 2021, “Residents, Peconic Land Trust hope to preserve property along New Suffolk Avenue.”
Thank you to the entire North Fork community (from Laurel to Orient, and everywhere in between!), and supporters from across the island, for your generous and passionate support of this project. Conservation does not happen alone, and we couldn’t do it without you. An extra special thanks to our Steering Committee for their unwavering leadership in moving this project forward:

Interested in learning more about the next phase of this project, or have additional questions about how you can help? Please contact us:
Alison Delaney, Sr. Manager of Major & Planned Gifts: ADelaney@PeconicLandTrust.org, or 631.283.3195, x144.
Holly Sanford, Senior Project Manager: HSanford@PeconicLandTrust.org, or 631.283.3195, x126.

Photo Credit: Rita Rooney
![block.image[0].title](/assets/images/Deep-Hole-Creek_Concept-Map_11.21.jpg)
Details:
- Location: 4180 New Suffolk Avenue (intersection of Marratooka Road), in Mattituck
- Size: 15 acres
![block.image[0].title](/assets/images/Field-Water_3162316-4.jpg)
Photo Credit: Rita Rooney
Deep Hole Creek Donors (as of August 12, 2022):
Anonymous
Adam and Lisa Ableman
Jerome Adler and Beth Lebowitz
Linda and Paul Auriemma
Kendal and Michael Bayer
Kathleen Kmet Becker
Peter Benedek
Judi Bird
Richard Bird
Edward Booth
Lawrence J. Bowles
Kathryn and Donald Boyle
Joshua Brand and Brooks McEwen
Neboysha and Prunella Brashich
Nancy Butkus
Christine Butler and Gregory Tobias
Jessica and Matthew Carballal
Bill Carmean and Nancy Ross
Clifford and Karen Cid
Barbara Close and J. Courtney Hoblock
Frederic Cohen
Michael and Robin Colapietro
Joanne and Anthony Colletta
Steve Curry and Carol Groneman
Joseph D’Angelo
Diana DeJesus and Derrick Ciccone
Alison Delaney and Aaron Bokros
Kathy Delaney Glenn and Ned Glenn
David Dempsey and Deborah Bennett
Jerry Diffley
Carole G. Donlin
Elizabeth Stark Dugan
William Edwards and Amei Wallach
Robert Eisenstat and Doris Brautigan
Mary Eisenstein
Joy and Jonathan Ellinghaus
Ann ffolliott
Hans Flick and Celeste Kime
Forward Current Foundation
Bob and Suzie Fox
Drs. Dorothy and Richard Fragaszy
Alex Friedman and Erica Tannenbaum
Clayton Gates and Jennifer Jacobs
Judith and Robert Goldman
Lisa A. Grattan
Israel Grosberg and Cathy Robin
James Haag
John and Sally Henry
Peter Hindmarsh and Julia Stambules
Douglas and Leslie Hirsch
Jon Hlafter and Claudia Hamilton
Mary Kane
Christopher Keating and Megan Joyce
Susan King
Stephanie Konarski
Lisa and Jonathan Kratter
Aurélie Lang
Robert Lehrburger and Sharyn Kohen
Alfred Levitt and Megan Bowles
David and Meredith Little
Susan and Joseph Loiacono
Neil and Amelia MacDonald
Lucy and Alastair Maitland
Anne Marino and Bernie Telsey
George Marinos
Terrence Martin and Rebeca Stokes
Adriana Martinez and Matthew Werstein
Pat Mathews
Carolyn McCall
McCall Family
Scott McDavid and Maegan Hinton
Marge McDonnell
Patricia McIntyre
Alice and Peter Mignerey
William and Patricia Milford
Richard and Sally Miller
Evan and Beth Minogue
New Suffolk Civic Association
Margaret Newman and Peter Marren
L. Normandia
Kathy and Chris Perretta
Kathryn Casey Quigley and Ryan Quigley
Kris and Dominic Randolph
James F. Reeve
Tom and Denise Riecker
Marilyn and David Rivkin
John Roberts and Lenor Buckley
John Rooney and Dorothy Phillips-Rooney
Drs. Lori and Scott Rosen
Clarissa, Stephen, and Asen Roussan
Michelle Roussan
Rino Salsedo and Yvette DeBow
Dean Sambach
Barbara Schnitzler and William Finkelstein
Nicolas Shearman
Elizabeth and Robert Sheehan
Shannon and Michael Simon
Anne and Ron Smith
Frederick and Nancy Smith
Mr. and Mrs. William Stanton
Joshua Steinberg and Ayumi Hata
Joan Vitale Strong
Rev. and Mrs. George and Lynn Summers
Mike and Liz Sweeney
Ivonne Torres
Bernard and Jane Turchiano
Jim Underwood
Elisa Urbanelli and Alec Hemer
Joseph Vangi
Elizabeth Vitale
Beverly Vlcek
Tom and Isabel Wacker
Randy Wade and Martin Heitner
Amerika and Bradd Williamson
Patricia and Frederick Yosca
![block.image[0].title](/assets/images/DHC-Sunset.png)
Photo Credit: D. Dellaquila
Visitor Information
The Deep Hole Creek parcel is viewable from New Suffolk Avenue and Marratooka Road in Mattituck. Since this parcel is expected to continue to be privately held and potentially cultivated, there is no public access.
There is, however, great public benefit from the protection of this land by contributing to the water quality and scenic vista of this area. We welcome your participation in this community fundraising project through consideration of a donation to support this acquisition, or by sharing our website with friends and neighbors to increase awareness. Thank you!
Deep Hole Creek Conservation
4180 New Suffolk Ave, Mattituck, NY 11952
Get Involved
To donate, click here. Contact Alison Delaney, Sr. Manager of Major & Planned Gifts, 631.283.3195, ext. 144 and Holly Sanford, Senior Project Manager, 631.283.3195, ext. 126 for more information.
Give
Help us protect 15 acres of waterfront farmland in Southold Town from a seven-lot subdivision!
Donate Now